| Rank | Player | Club | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |  Sophia Elfrink | AFC Columbia Women | Goalkeeper |
| 2 | Joe Roder | AFC Columbia Men | Goalkeeper |
| 3 | Patrick Wisnewski | AFC Columbia Men | Forward |
| 4 | Lance Patrick | - | Goalkeeper |
| 5 |  Ryan Harrisskitt | AFC Columbia Men | Goalkeeper |
| 6 | April Mason | AFC Columbia Women | Goalkeeper |
| 7 |  Pieter Hailombe | - | Defender |
| 8 | Carsyn R Osborn | AFC Columbia Women | Midfielder |
| 9 | Jacob Moore | AFC Columbia Men | Midfielder |
| 10 | Ellie Hilton | AFC Columbia Women | Defender |
| 11 | Alexis Willingham | AFC Columbia Women | Midfielder |
| 12 | Connor Blitz | - | Defender |
| 13 | Jackson Schrum | AFC Columbia Men | Defender |
| 14 | Kailee Wisber | AFC Columbia Women | Forward |
| 15 | Cole Gerstenberger | AFC Columbia Men | Defender |
| 16 | Lauren Helmert | AFC Columbia Women | Midfielder |
| 17 | Samantha Poehlmann | AFC Columbia Women | Forward |
| 18 |  Issa Butoyi | AFC Columbia Men | Forward |
| 19 | Nicholas Baird | - | Defender |
| 20 | Steve Marion | AFC Columbia Men | Midfielder |
| 21 | Izzy Cole | AFC Columbia Women | Midfielder |
| 22 | Heidi Gundy | AFC Columbia Women | Forward |
| 23 | Joey Koetting | AFC Columbia Men | Forward |
| 24 | Caroline Cole | AFC Columbia Women | Midfielder |
| 25 | Erik Rajoy | AFC Columbia Men | Midfielder |
| 26 |  Tarnue Tyler | - | Midfielder |
| 27 | Clay Faiman | AFC Columbia Men | Forward |
| 28 | Joey Spotanski | AFC Columbia Men | Forward |
| 29 | Amanda Coppeti | AFC Columbia Men | Forward |
| 30 | Eli Sherman | AFC Columbia Men | Midfielder |
| 31 | Kelly Ross | AFC Columbia Women | Forward |
| 32 | Michael Okiring | - | Midfielder |
| 33 | Maddie Schrader | AFC Columbia Women | Midfielder |
| 34 | Zack Fischer | - | Defender |
| 35 | Travis Smith | AFC Columbia Men | Defender |
| 36 | Chloe Overkamp | AFC Columbia Women | Defender |
| 37 | Will O’Laughlin | - | Defender |
| 38 | Samantha Blashak | AFC Columbia Women | Midfielder |
| 39 | Bukuru Dieudone | AFC Columbia Men | Midfielder |
| 40 | Paul Morpugo | AFC Columbia Men | Forward |
| 41 | Leah M Hays | AFC Columbia Women | Midfielder |
| 42 | Dominic McKeown | AFC Columbia Men | Forward |
| 43 | Kayla Juengermann | AFC Columbia Women | Midfielder |
| 44 | Samuel Allen | - | Forward |
| 45 | Rece Gilmore | AFC Columbia Men | Forward |
| 46 | Faith Rackers | AFC Columbia Women | Forward |
| 47 | Elliot Goodwin | AFC Columbia Men | Midfielder |
| 48 | Mackenzie Boyle | AFC Columbia Women | Midfielder |
| 49 | Michael Bhat | - | Forward |
| 50 | Lake Gott | AFC Columbia Men | Defender |
| 51 |  Samuel Appiah | AFC Columbia Men | Midfielder |
| 52 | Brandon Rettke | - | Midfielder |
| 53 |  Daniel Miranda | AFC Columbia Men | Defender |
| 54 | Harrison Bray | - | Midfielder |
| 55 | Mako Makoanyane | AFC Columbia Men | Midfielder |
| 56 | Jordan Ferrao | AFC Columbia Men | Forward |
| 57 |  Freddy Nene | - | Midfielder |
| 58 | Haley Steinke | AFC Columbia Women | Forward |
| 59 | Carter Redford | AFC Columbia Men | Midfielder |
| 60 |  Luka Kuol | - | Midfielder |
| 61 | Jessica Kampeter | AFC Columbia Women | Goalkeeper |
| 62 | Nathan Durdle | AFC Columbia Men | Forward |
| 63 | Hannah Juengermann | AFC Columbia Women | Midfielder |
| 64 | Kazimir Kromwijk | AFC Columbia Men | Goalkeeper |
